Jump to content

Talk:Seeking a Sanctuary

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

November 2010 changes

[edit]

I have reverted most of the changes made during November 2010. Two editors disagreed on the changes, and I give the following reasons for replacing original content:

  • replaced reviews. There is no logical reason for removing reviews of the book, which are the primary basis of the article
  • replaced category about Adventist media
  • the claim the book takes a liberal Adventist perspective on theology is inaccurate and original research. It rather comes across as relatively neutral history
  • discussion of inerrancy is original research because it is highly interpretative, and draws sources together to make new claims
  • comment "Some authors have described it as the best book about the church..." replaced. This is simply a summary of many of the published reviews of the book. It is a neutral comment. This is a widely held view by experts.
  • replaced Adventist Forum meeting, as this is relevant, verifiable material
  • clarified sources for some points
  • inline external links - I have kept this change, not reverting it, but moved them to the "External links" section

Colin MacLaurin (talk) 04:29, 3 December 2010 (UTC)[reply]