Jump to content

Wikipedia:Article assessment/1980s comedy films/This Is Spinal Tap

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Assessment Article assessment
1980s comedy films
Assessment completed
6 March 2006
12 March 2006
Assessments
A Fish Called Wanda

The Adventures of Baron Munchausen
Back to the Future Good article
Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure
Brazil (film)
Coming to America
Crocodile Dundee
Ferris Bueller's Day Off
Ghostbusters
Heathers
Honey, I Shrunk the Kids Poor article
Little Shop of Horrors (1986 film)
Monty Python's Life of Brian
The Naked Gun
The Princess Bride (film)
A Room with a View (film) Poor article
Spaceballs
This Is Spinal Tap Good article
Three Men and a Baby
Time Bandits
Twins (film)
UHF (film)

Assessment of an article under the topic 1980s comedy films.


Article: This Is Spinal Tap

Details of the assessment method can be found at the main page. Feel free to add comments when you assess an article, or use the talk page for discussion.


Review by DMurphy

[edit]
  • Coverage and factuality: 8
Could use more than two inline references, but other than that it's got pretty good coverage. Will need to be expanded a bit more to become a FA though.
  • Writing style: 8.5
A bit dry in parts, but informative.
  • Structure: 8.5
Could use a cast section with links to the cast members, otherwise the structure is good.
  • Aesthetics: 9
I'd like to see pictures spread throughout the article to space things out... other than that, pretty good.
  • Overall: 9

A few minor flaws add up with this one... other than that, a little expansion and more references and it could be at FA level.

Review by [name]

[edit]
  • Coverage and factuality:
  • Writing style:
  • Structure:
  • Aesthetics:
  • Overall: